How to Negotiate Your Salary

By Girl BossFinance6 min read

A step by step guide to researching your market pay, making the ask and negotiating the full package: base, bonus, title and time.

How To Negotiate Your Salary. Close up of two people shaking hands in a business agreement
Photo: Broad Bean Media, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr

Here's the part no one puts in the offer packet: the number you're handed is rarely the real number. Negotiate your first salary instead of accepting it, and the gap is worth, by one widely cited estimate, $5,000 more each year. It matters more for women: in the United States, women's earnings have held at roughly 80 to 82 percent of men's for most of the past two decades, according to Harvard Law School's Program on Negotiation. That gap doesn't close with one dramatic ask. It closes with a researched number, a clear script and the nerve to use both, whether you're staring at a new offer or walking into your boss's office for a raise. Girl Boss keeps this at one link: three steps, researched once, to use the first time you need them and every time after.

Research your number

Start with what people in your role, industry and location actually get paid, not what you hope they do. Settle on an ideal offer, a minimum you'd accept, and the non-cash benefits that would make a lower number still worth it, before you say any of them out loud.

For hard numbers, start with the federal government's wage survey: free, official estimates covering about 830 occupations as of its May 2025 data, broken into percentile bands, the 10th, 25th, 50th (the median), 75th and 90th, so you see the real range rather than one average. It covers every state, DC, several U.S. territories and roughly 530 metro and nonmetro areas, and shows how much location and industry shift the number: pay for computer systems analysts, for one, runs high in aerospace manufacturing and lower in colleges and universities. Pew Research Center's gender pay gap by age cohort chart adds the comparison that matters here: women's median hourly pay as a percentage of men's, age group by age group, from Current Population Survey data. Cross check at least two of LinkedIn Salary, Glassdoor or Levels.fyi before you land on a target number.

Make the ask

The moment matters as much as the number. For a new job, negotiate after you have a written offer and before you accept it, not during the interview and not after you've signed. Open with an anchor: a specific range, which sets the terms for the rest of the conversation. Aim 10 to 15 percent above what you were offered: 50 percent higher reads as disconnected from the number in front of you, 10 to 15 percent reads as someone who did her homework. If a week passes with no reply, follow up seven to ten days after your first message, not sooner.

A raise with your current employer works differently: you're not comparing offers, you're making a case, your research, your results, your number. If the answer is a partial yes, don't let it drop; propose revisiting the number in three to six months, with specifics on what gets you there. And say your number first and plainly: when employers ask candidates what they expect to earn, Matthew Pollard found in Lioness Magazine that candidates routinely name a figure $5,000 to $10,000 lower than he was prepared to offer. Don't talk yourself down before anyone else gets the chance.

Negotiate the full package

Salary is one line item, not the whole negotiation. Dr. Deborah Kolb, who wrote 'Negotiating At Work,' makes a related point: don't let the conversation stop at a number. Your title, your schedule and your scope are worth negotiating too. Even when the salary line really is capped, the rest of the package usually isn't: Create & Cultivate writer Arianna Schioldager negotiated a free gym membership and a cell phone into her own compensation, in a piece the outlet first published in April 2019 and has kept updated since. Within a year, her company began offering free memberships to everyone. If pay really is fixed, ask for a better title instead: a more marketable title now helps you negotiate the next promotion, or the next job. And get it in writing: save every email from the negotiation so there's no argument later about what was actually promised.

An outside offer is leverage, used well. Writing in Lioness Magazine, Pollard tells of coaching a woman at IBM: she had a competing offer worth 10 percent more, brought it to her employer, and walked away with a 15 percent raise plus a promotion.

What you're up against

It helps to know what you're negotiating against, because it isn't only the number. In 2006, Carnegie Mellon's Linda Babcock and colleagues found that women initiate negotiations, salary negotiations most of all, far less often than men. A 2007 study by Hannah Riley Bowles, Linda Babcock and Lei Lai showed why that caution might be rational: evaluators penalized women who negotiated for a higher salary, while men who negotiated the same way weren't penalized at all. It hasn't gone away. A 2018 study found women ask for raises about as often as men but don't land them as often; a related study run with control groups in Australia found the men who asked were about 5 percent more likely to actually get the raise.

The newer research complicates that story in a useful way. A 2024 survey of nearly 1,000 graduates of a top business school found more women than men negotiated their first salary out of the program, 54 percent of women against 44 percent of men; a second survey of close to 2,000 alumni found 64 percent of the women and 59 percent of the men said they'd negotiated a promotion or higher pay. Women were already doing the asking. Ten years out, though, their pay had slid to roughly 63 percent of their male peers', down from about 88 percent at graduation. As one of that study's researchers, Jessica Kennedy, put it, women are doing their part by negotiating, but that alone won't close the gender pay gap. Credit works against women too: McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 Women in the Workplace report found women are less likely than men to get recognized for a team's wins. And the gap isn't flat across women: the National Women's Law Center puts the numbers at 67 cents for Black women and 57 cents for Latina women, against a white, non-Hispanic man's dollar at the same level. None of that is a reason to stay quiet. It's the reason to ask with a number in hand, not a hope.

The lesson worth keeping

Here's the lesson worth keeping: the ask is not the risky part. Staying quiet while the market moves on without you is. Research your number with real data, not a guess. Write the ask down, with a specific range instead of a hope. Negotiate the whole package, not just the base. And when the answer is still no, treat it as a timeline, not a verdict: ask when, not just whether. Pay isn't handed out for good behavior. It's negotiated, line by line, by the people willing to ask for it twice.

Quick answers

When should I negotiate a new job offer

After you have the offer in writing and before you accept it, not during the interview and not after you've signed.

How much higher should my counteroffer be

Aim for 10 to 15 percent above what you were offered, not 50 percent higher.

What if my boss only partly agrees to a raise

Propose a concrete check in within three to six months rather than letting the request drop.

Where can I find official pay data

Start with the federal government's Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program, which covers about 830 occupations and roughly 530 metro and nonmetro areas.

Sources

  1. How to Negotiate Your Salary and Actually Get Paid More | Girlboss
  2. The Grand, Undermining Lie Of “Asking For More” | Girlboss
  3. Salary Negotiation Email Template: 4 Copy-Paste Scripts That Get Results | Girlboss
  4. How to Negotiate Benefits at Work — Create & Cultivate
  5. How much could I be earning? Using Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics data during salary negotiations : U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
  6. Gender pay gap by age cohort | Pew Research Center
  7. In Salary Negotiations, Women Do Ask - PON - Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School
  8. 10 Negotiating Tips For Women - Lioness Magazine

More to read